Mystery Tackle Box

A fun and affordable way to discover new fishing products every month. VIEW PLANS

0 / 5
Add to favorites Compare
Price: $14.99

In this review of Mystery Tackle Box, we’ll go over the basics and show you exactly what you might expect to receive in each box. Whether you like salt water fishing, bass, or trout, you’ll find something from MTB that you should read in this review!

What is Mystery Tackle Box?

If you’re like any other fisherman out there, you likely have piles and piles of lures, hooks, and lines lying around the garage, the basement, and under the back seat in your car. The stuff you do have is disorganized and might even be old or unusable. Getting good lures, bait, and general fishing gear to try on your favorite fishing spot isn’t the fun part. You just want to go fishing and have your gear ready to go.

Mystery Tackle Box can turn you into a finesse fisherman pro. With fishing gear tailored to the species of fish and even location, you will always be prepared with tried and true lures. It’s fun to get a box in the mail, throw it in the pickup with your rod, and drive on out to your spot. When you get there, open the box up and try stuff out!

What Comes in the Mystery Tackle Box?

One of the best parts about MTB is that you can pick exactly what you need. While you will be surprised what you get, you know what fish you should be fishing for. If you’re a big trout fisherman, then sign up for the trout box. They have boxes with hand selected gear for the following species:

  • Bass
  • Inshore Saltwater
  • Walleye
  • Panfish
  • Catfish
  • Trout
  • Ice Fishing (when in season)

Mystery Tackle Box Bass

One of their most popular boxes – contains crankbaits, spinnerbait, jigs, and senkos.

Check out the contents of one of our recent Pro Bass Boxes! Get $10 off your first box of any species with code MTBNEW

A post shared by Mystery Tackle Box (@mysterytacklebox) on


Mystery Tackle Box Inshore Saltwater

Ready to go for saltwater fish? Find the hooks, shrimp, and grubs you need!

Mystery Tackle Box Trout

Get a range of gear for trout fishing like hooks, tubes, spinners, and spoons. Check out the images below to see some samples for the trout MTB.

Mystery Tackle Box Unboxing

How much does MTB cost?

For every fish species box they provide, there are three 3 options.

  1. Regular Mystery Tackle Box
  2. Mystery Tackle Box Pro
  3. Mystery Tackle Box Local


Mystery Tackle Box Pricing Plans Monthly 3 Month Subscription 6 Month Subscription 12 Month Subscription
Regular $14.99/mo $14.50/mo $14.25/mo $13.75/mo
Pro $24.99/mo $24.00/mo $24.00/mo $23.00/mo
Local $29.99/mo $29.99/mo $29.99/mo $29.99/mo

All local boxes are $29.99. Each box has free shipping, no sales tax, and can be canceled at any time.

Mystery Tackle Box Coupon Codes and Discounts

  • $10 off with coupon code “MTBNEW”
  • $10 off with coupon code “GOOGAN”
  • $5 off with coupon code “FIRSTBOX5”
  • 10% off with coupon code “GIFTS10PCT”
  • 10% off with coupon code “DADS10”


Is Mystery Tackle Box Worth It?

If you compare the value of what you get in each box, then yes it is absolutely worth it. Every box comes with a sheet on what each lure or package costs and it is always cheaper to pay for the box subscription than going out and individually buying the tackle yourself.

Typical fisherman spend anywhere between $25-50 a month on fishing gear. Mystery tackle box provides a happy medium for getting this gear to your front doorstep and at a fraction of the cost.

Will you actually use everything they give you? That’s a very different question. This will depend greatly on your level and skill of fishing.

On the other hand, they do a great job at informing you with videos on how to use certain types of bait. If you are learning how to fish, this is a great way to learn the different lures! Here’s a great video on how to fish a drop shot:



Things you should know

With monthly subscription boxes like this, one thing you need to keep in mind is whether you will use it all the time or not. Do you fish all year long? Maybe you target different types of fish at different times of the year. Keep this in mind when you subscribe for more than one month at a time!

If you live in the Northeast, maybe you’d do ice fishing in late winter, then trout in the spring, and then bass in the summer. Not one box would satisfy your fishing patterns throughout the year. However, if you live in a steady climate area that allows you to fish the same spots all year long. Then the longer subscriptions are definitely worth it!

MTB also carries some products in their online store. You can buy a number of fishing related items that aren’t included in your monthly box subscription that will come with next month’s box.

Mystery Tackle Box Competitors and Alternatives

Lucky Tackle Box – LTB has a lot of options that MTB might not have. If you fly fish, they have a great box for you! However, you could go back and forth on which box is really best if you target the same fish.


  • Price $14.99
  • Slogan A fun and affordable way to discover new fishing products every month. VIEW PLANS
  • Brand color